Demotions

​

Definitions

​

A demotion occurs when an employee is moved to a lower position or rank within a company, often accompanied by a reduction in salary, responsibilities, or status. Demotions can be the result of disciplinary action, organizational restructuring, or performance issues. However, not all demotions are legally justifiable, and employees have rights that must be respected.

​

Legal Requirements

​

For a demotion to be lawful in the UK, several legal requirements must be met:

​

• Contractual Agreement: The terms of your employment contract are crucial. If your contract includes a clause allowing for demotion in specific circumstances, your employer may have the right to demote you. However, the demotion must be reasonable and in line with the contract.

• Fair Process: Employers must follow a fair process before demoting an employee. This typically includes conducting a proper investigation, providing the employee with an opportunity to respond to allegations, and considering alternative actions.

• No Discrimination: Demotions must not be based on discriminatory reasons, such as age, gender, race, or disability. Discriminatory demotions are unlawful and can be challenged.

• Constructive Dismissal: If an employee is demoted without just cause or proper procedure, they may have grounds to resign and claim constructive dismissal, arguing that the employer’s actions breached the employment contract.

 

Real life Examples with Case Law

​​

• Case Example: Edwards v. Chesterfield Royal Hospital NHS Foundation Trust (2011)

  • Situation: Edwards was demoted following a disciplinary process that he argued was unfair and not conducted according to the agreed procedures.

  • Outcome: The Supreme Court ruled that Edwards could not claim damages for breach of contract beyond the financial losses he directly suffered as a result of the demotion.

• Case Example: McBride v. Scottish Police Authority (2016)

  • Situation: McBride was demoted as part of a restructuring process, which she claimed was unfair and amounted to discrimination.

  • Outcome: The tribunal found in favor of McBride, ruling that the demotion was unfair and discriminatory, and she was awarded compensation.

• Case Example: King v. University Court of the University of St. Andrews (2002)

  • Situation: King was demoted after a new manager took over and changed the structure of his department, reducing his responsibilities.

  • Outcome: The tribunal found that the demotion was not justified and constituted a breach of contract, leading to a successful claim for constructive dismissal.

• Case Example: Brown v. London Borough of Croydon (2007)

  • Situation: Brown was demoted following allegations of misconduct, which he denied. He claimed the process was biased and unfair.

  • Outcome: The tribunal ruled in favor of Brown, finding that the disciplinary process was flawed and the demotion was unjustified.

• Case Example: Adeshina v. St George's University Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust (2017)

  • Situation: Adeshina was demoted after a disciplinary hearing, which she claimed was conducted improperly and with bias.

  • Outcome: The Employment Appeal Tribunal (EAT) found that the Trust had acted fairly, and Adeshina's appeal was dismissed.

• Case Example: Smith v. British Bakeries Ltd (1999)

  • Situation: Smith was demoted after refusing to accept changes to his working hours. He claimed that the demotion was a breach of contract.

  • Outcome: The tribunal found in favour of Smith, ruling that the demotion was not justified and awarded him compensation for breach of contract.

• Case Example: Bailie v. Scotbake Ltd (2010)

  • Situation: Bailie was demoted following a company restructuring, which he argued was done without proper consultation or consideration of his contract.

  • Outcome: The tribunal ruled that the demotion was unfair, and Bailie was awarded compensation for constructive dismissal.

• Case Example: Cox v. Sun Alliance Life Ltd (2001)

  • Situation: Cox was demoted due to alleged poor performance, but he argued that the targets set were unrealistic and the process was unfair.

  • Outcome: The tribunal found that the demotion was unjustified, and Cox was awarded compensation for breach of contract.

• Case Example: Johnson v. Unisys Ltd (2001)

  • Situation: Johnson was demoted and then dismissed after raising concerns about unethical practices at work. He claimed the demotion was a retaliatory action.

  • Outcome: The House of Lords ruled that Johnson could not claim damages for the manner of his dismissal, but his demotion was found to be unfair.

• Case Example: Mackenzie v. North Lanarkshire Council (2005)

  • Situation: Mackenzie was demoted after being accused of misconduct, which he denied. He claimed the disciplinary process was flawed and biased.

  • Outcome: The tribunal found in favour of Mackenzie, ruling that the demotion was unjustified and awarded him compensation for constructive dismissal.

​​​

How We Can Help

​

• Evaluate Your Case: We will thoroughly assess the circumstances surrounding your resignation to determine if you have a strong claim for constructive dismissal.

• Gather Evidence: We will assist you in collecting the necessary evidence to support your claim, including documentation of the breach of contract and any relevant communications with your employer.

• Negotiate on Your Behalf: If appropriate, we can negotiate with your former employer to seek a settlement before proceeding to a tribunal.

• Represent You in Tribunal: Should your case go to tribunal, we will provide expert representation to ensure your rights are protected and to maximize your chances of a successful outcome.

​